Self-Loathing Professors

Robert Alter spoke of literature professors who don’t like literature in his book The Pleasure of Reading (reviewed here).  Professor Bruce Fleming likewise lamented that literary studies are killing literature by forcing students to learn the jargon and arcane techniques of “literary studies” rather than actually reading great literature.

Hector Avalos is a professor of the Bible who hates the Bible.   In an essay on the Society of Biblical Literature forum he sites with approval a literature professor’s views that

Shakespeare’s works, for example, have no intrinsic value, but they function as cultural capital insofar as “knowing Shakespeare” helps provide entry into elite educated society. The academic study of literature, in general, functions to maintain class distinctions rather than to help humanity in any practical manner.

Avalos then applies this critique to the Bible:

Similarly, the Bible has no intrinsic value or merit. Its value is a social construct, and the SBL is the agent of an elite class that wishes to retain its own value and employment by fostering the idea that biblical studies should matter.

Avalos is not really a self-loathing professor.  He admits to loving his work, and has contributed valuable research on medical anthropology in antiquity and in early Christianity.  His thesis–that providing universal access to free health care was the key factor in the spread of early Christianity–is interesting (review of Health Care and the Rise of Christianity here).

And I’m sure he enjoys the perks of his tenured position at Iowa State.  He might as well enjoy it while he can, because if they read his book The End of Biblical Studies, his position will be abolished–along with literature professorships.

Professor Guillermo Gonzalez won’t be enjoying tenure at Iowa State, though.  Even though his academic credentials were impeccable, Gonzalez was denied tenure because of his belief that the universe displays evidence of–gasp–being designed.  An email exchange between a physics professor at ISU and Hector Avalos is part of the evidence that Gonzalez was a victim of illegal ideological discrimination.

The ideological crime Gonzalez committed was suggesting in his book (and PBS video) The Privileged Planet that the earth is not only uniquely formed and situated to sustain life, but that it is also uniquely situated to allow human intelligence to observe and investigate the physical universe (More on Gonzalez here).

If only he had suggested that physics is an elite, privileged discipline that should be abolished–he might still be enjoying those privileges along with Dr. Avalos.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: